Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Did the Music Business Just Kill the Vinyl Revival? The Honest Broker

Growth in vinyl album sales have collapsed from 95% to 4% and that may be ominous news for the music industry.

Placing Vinyl Record on Cambridge Audio Alva Turntable

A few months ago, I wrote about returning to vinyl after giving up on it 34 years ago. 

But I was shocked at what I encountered. Few of the albums I wanted were available in vinyl. Prices were outrageously high. The whole market seemed designed to discourage buyers. 

I’d heard so many grand claims for the vinyl resurgence, but the reality was tremendously disappointing. And I was a late adopter—the revival had been going on for a decade, but record labels still didn’t have their act together.

In my case, I ended up buying vinyl albums, but mostly used ones. I simply couldn’t find new pressings of the records I wanted. This was fine for me, but lousy for musicians and labels—who make no money on the sale of a secondhand vinyl album. 

1950s Jukebox
1950s jukebox technology (Kenny Louie/Wikimedia Commons)

I have some experience in these matters—in my alternative career I worked with CEOs chasing after fast growth product categories. I know how they handle these situations. But, really, it’s no mystery. The strategies you use in this kind of business are very straightforward:

  1. You add manufacturing capacity aggressively—to make sure you have enough product to fuel growth.
  2. You bring down costs by getting scale advantages. But this only happens because unit costs drop as volume increases. So the single biggest goal is to grow sales as hard and fast as possible.
  3. You constantly reduce prices to keep demand building. In some cases, you even set prices below your costs to accelerate growth rates. When I originally saw companies do this I was skeptical—how can you make profits if you sell below your costs? But I soon learned that you eventually got a huge payback. 
  4. You keep expanding the product line, so that you constantly have something new and exciting to sell to every potential buyer. 
  5. You invest in R&D so that you eventually have a next generation technology to keep the growth going over the long haul. 

None of this is easy to do, but it isn’t impossible. It just takes investment, focus, management commitment, and hard work. And later you reap the benefits. You turn a small business into a huge one, and enjoy a big payday. 

“In the year 2023, even bowling alleys, bordellos, and bookies are more tech savvy than the major record labels.”

The record labels could have done that with vinyl. It was taking off—unit sales doubled in just 5 years. And these sales were insanely profitable, because much of the demand was for old music. So labels didn’t even have to pay to sign artists, and cover the costs of recording sessions. The music was already there, with the fixed costs amortized long ago.

They just had to press the bloody album and ship it to the store. How hard is that?

But what did the music industry do?

  • They hate running factories—which is hard work. So they tried to outsource manufacturing instead of building it themselves. Chronic shortages resulted.
  • They refuse to spend money on R&D, so they stayed with the same vinyl technology from the 1950s. In other words, the record business became the only entertainment industry in the world with no plan for technological innovation. In the year 2023, even bowling alleys, bordellos, and bookies are more tech savvy than the major record labels.
  • They want easy money, so they kept prices extremely high. That was bizarre because their R&D and catalog acquisition costs were essentially zero, and they could have priced vinyl aggressively. Instead they treated vinyl as a luxury product, even as they dreamed of it also becoming a mass market option. But you can’t do both without a careful market segmentation strategy—which the labels never even started thinking about. 
  • They love hype, so they focused on high visibility vinyl reissues, which look good in press releases, but couldn’t be bothered to make back catalog albums available. After a decade of the vinyl revival, they still hadn’t taken even basic steps in offering a wide product line. 

This is a lazy strategy—and the exact opposite of what they should have done. And the results are, of course, predictable. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Here’s what I predicted in my previous article.

The level of greed is off the charts. Because it’s so hard to make money in music nowadays, the labels have decided to squeeze as much cash as they can from vinyl fans. This is one area where Spotify and Apple don’t call the shots, so why not charge twenty dollars for vinyl? Or maybe thirty dollars is better. Hell, let’s ask for forty, and see who will buy?

In other words, a technology that is 70 years old—and in which labels have invested almost zero additional dollars—is priced as if it’s a hot new innovation requiring billions of dollars in startup capital. This is like taking your old shoes, and trying to sell them for twenty times what you paid for them.

In a market where retro is hot, you might get away with this—at least for a short time. Some of my readers will probably respond: Well, if Taylor Swift fans are willing to pay forty bucks, it’s a perfectly fair priceThat may be true, but it’s still a stupid price—because the vinyl revival won’t become a mass market phenomenon at these prices. I’ve spent a lot of time over the years studying the economics of pricing, and will tell you with absolute confidence that what record labels are doing right now will eventually be taught in business schools as a case study in mistaken priorities.

And now all this is starting to happen. Last week Luminate released its end-of-year figures for the music market. 

Despite all the hype, vinyl album unit sales only grew 4%. I’ve heard some people praising this in silly news stories about the continued growth in vinyl

But those numbers are a HUGE disappointment. 

Just a year ago, the industry was bragging about a vinyl market that had doubled in size in a single year. In just 12 months, demand had increased from 21.4 to 41.7 million units. 

But then in 2022, the growth rate collapsed from 95% to 4%. That’s not a slowdown—that’s slamming on the brakes right before you hit the brick wall. 

Check out the trend line—which tells you immediately that the amazing growth spurt of the last few years is now over. 

And if it wasn’t for Taylor Swift, the vinyl market would have actually declined in 2022. This one artist did more to support vinyl sales than the much hyped “Record Store Days.”

Taylor Swift and Record Store Day Album Sales 2022
Source: Luminate

But here’s an even more ominous sign. Half of vinyl buyers don’t own a record player. They apparently bought the Taylor Swift album as a kind of memorabilia—something a little nicer than a band T-shirt. 

This can’t be a good thing for the record business. After all, how many records are you going to buy if you don’t have a turntable? This is like trying to sell Teslas as a status symbol to people who don’t drive.

Vinyl Buyers in 2022
Source: Luminate

Maybe some brilliant minds at the major labels are already thinking ahead to the next fad—the supposed cassette tape revival. 

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

But those folks are blowing smoke. Cassette sales are minuscule. Despite all the hype, they are still below a half million units—roughly the streams The Weeknd gets over a weekend. 

Here’s the bottom line on album sales in all formats (physical and digital). The tiny growth in vinyl and cassettes isn’t even enough to compensate for the drop in digital album purchases. 

On an aggregate level, consumers are simply not buying music. They prefer to stream it for pennies rather than purchase it for dollars. 

Album Sales Reported in 2022
Source: Luminate

As these figures make clear, vinyl has stalled out around the size of the moribund compact disk market. 

I guess it could be worse—but it couldn’t be much worse. The music industry took its fastest growing segment and killed it through greed and laziness. 

If they had followed the standard playbook for growth industries (outlined above), they could have brought vinyl back as a mass market option. They might have easily convinced 40-50 million consumers to buy a dozen vinyl albums per year. That would create a total market more than 10 times as large as the current one.

In that kind of world, musicians would benefit. Record stores would thrive. Fan loyalty would increase. And record labels would have more cash for themselves and a legitimate way of making money that doesn’t rely on Silicon Valley technocrats and hostile streaming platforms. 

In short, the culture would be healthier.

Maybe this can still happen. But once you blow an opportunity like this, you rarely get a second chance. 

For my part, I have zero confidence in the people who made this mess in the first place. Nothing will get fixed until they’re replaced by visionaries who can actually lead the music business in the right direction. 

Sometimes those people emerge—as I recently reported with Barnes & Noble, where a new leader at the top reversed course and fixed longstanding problems. And I know that people like that exist in the music world. I’ve even met some of them—but not in executive suite of any major label.

Ted Gioia is a leading music writer, and author of eleven books including The History of Jazz and Music: A Subversive History. This article originally appeared on his Substack column and newsletter The Honest Broker.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.



  1. RJ

    January 22, 2023 at 1:13 pm

    Price is definitely keeping me for purchasing more vinyl. Even the used market is insane now. I actually hope sales stagnate so that prices start to go down.

    • Ian White

      January 23, 2023 at 11:35 am




    • GB

      January 24, 2023 at 4:50 am

      New vinyl quality control can’t be helping. Off-center, noisy and warped pressings for $40+ aren’t that fun after the first time it happens to a new vinyl buyer.

    • Corey T.

      January 28, 2023 at 12:37 am

      I’m all for a crash in the vinyl market. Then maybe I can get some of the albums that have more than tripled in price in 2 years.

      • Ian White

        January 28, 2023 at 12:26 pm


        I do think Blue Note have been rather fair with their pricing on the Tone Poet releases. As I reported last week, some of the major labels will be raising their prices in February by 20 to 30%.


        Ian White

  2. Mike Cornell

    January 23, 2023 at 1:40 pm

    I love vinyl, but not at the current prices. Why buy an LP when you can get a CD for a fraction of the price? Records should not be a luxury item.

    • Ian White

      January 23, 2023 at 3:06 pm


      Just wait until February 16th. 30% increase coming from some labels.

      Records are going to price themselves out of the market and I don’t care how many new plants they build, the demand is already slowing because nobody wants to spend $30 to $50 for a record.

      I usually buy 30 to 50 new records each year. I purchased 12 in 2022. Lowest number in a decade.

      I’ve purchased 25 used CDs so far in 2023. For $75 total.

      Ian White

    • Dan Martinez

      January 25, 2023 at 3:36 am

      Your missing the point Digital album sales are down Almost 23 percent. Yet in an inflation year vinyl albums are up 4 percent. It’s digital that dropping fast. Analog sound better than Digital. Also vinyl is sold out cause not enough pressing plants to handle the demand

  3. Matt Bradish

    January 24, 2023 at 3:53 am

    I’ve always suspected the major labels wished that physical forms of music would just go away. They fired most of their sales staff in 2008. I suspect they thought vinyl was fad that would just fade. I’ve owned a record store since 1993 and the interest in vinyl has only grown. I had many customers in the 90s tire of the brick-walled mastered sound the major labels used and they began seeking out vinyl. From my perspective, this revival really hit high gear in 2004. I had many customers tell me then, if they couldn’t buy it on vinyl, they’d just download it for free somewhere. Then the panademic made it very popular, for I sell an object you have to be at home to enjoy. I have never had a down year, though comparing 2008 to 2009 was nearly flat, only a 1% increase from the previous year. For me, many of the past 20 years have seen 8-15% year over year increases in sales. 2021 was 51%. Listening and learning from your market is key; in person, in the trenches; not in a boardroom or ivy tower. I’m not convinced many in my industry do not actually understand, enjoy or like vinyl, let alone music for that matter. Therefore, they don’t know their customer.

    I agree that it’s too expensive, but until more labels / distros invest in manufacturing, this will not change. Many indies are still keeping it correctly priced, and that’s where all the good artists start.

    • Dennis

      January 24, 2023 at 5:01 pm

      Matt Bradish, when you wrote that you’ve had 8-15% annual growth is that in new vinyl or new and used? there are 3 record stores (excluding department and book stores that offer a limited selection of new records) where i live. my casual observation is that the bulk of their business is used. thanks.

  4. kingRidiculous

    January 24, 2023 at 11:45 am

    People may be buying LPs as gifts, so that may be why 50% of buyers don’t have turntables.

    There is also a need for higher quality but still affordable players. Where is the innovation in turntables? I’d like to see a linear tracking turntable controllable by smartphone app that would allow you to select tracks to play next. The app could also provide album information.
    I’d love to have a new slot-loading player that could play both sides of the record.

  5. vinyl1

    January 28, 2023 at 3:25 am

    There is a high-end vinyl business where companies like Mobile Fidelity and Acoustic Sounds sell expensive high-quality limited editions for $50. Their customers spend thousands of dollars on turntables and cartridges, so will buy at that price. Heck, the Electric Recording Company sells out their editions at $300 a pop – of course, they’re very limited.

    But it’s not really feasible for records to sell competitively into the mass market. The process and machinery are very expensive in the modern world – the cost of lacquers and plating has gotten very high, the raw vinyl is not cheap, skilled technicians are needed to maintain and run the presses. Most of the mass-market labels are producing low-quality records – warped, pressed off center, damaged in handling. I suspect the mass market buyers will disappear as they realize how difficult the medium is.

    • Ian White

      January 28, 2023 at 4:21 pm

      A few thoughts on this (and I agree with a number of your points)…

      There are a number of new plants opening this year in the United States and that will certainly take some of the pressure off the supply chain issues that are plaguing the industry. However, the high prices are finally starting to have an impact for the simple fact that inflation has forced people to spend less money on non-essential products.

      I’m the EIC of a high-end audio publication and spent 75% less in 2022 on new records because I had to spend $4,000 more on food (family of 5) and a lot more on gasoline. If I’m not spending money on records (and I have 2,200 records) — and can get a discount from most companies being in the industry — that’s not a good sign for some of the labels that usually get my money.

      I think the forthcoming increases by the major labels is going to hurt sales dramatically this year. Everyone was cheering the 4% level of growth in 2022 for new vinyl sales, but take a quick read through our coverage of RIAA sales data for the past 3 years. That’s a remarkable drop in growth.

      Vinyl isn’t going anywhere but I agree that the mainstream consumer is going to start fading away.


      Ian White

  6. Craven Moore

    January 30, 2023 at 2:13 am

    Not to delve into the price barrier of a decent turntable for newbies. I personally am not a fan of vinyl but am assisting a niece with her newfound hobby. It’s not a pretty picture out there. JMHO.

  7. Lash

    January 30, 2023 at 2:28 am

    And guess who gets screwed the most: Us. The recording artists. As always.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You May Also Like


The COVID pandemic took a lot from us including thousands of restaurants. But a small vintage audio and record store in thriving in Brooklyn.


Bluesville Records celebrates America's bedrock music genre with release of its first two audiophile quality vinyl reissues on June 7, 2024.


Turntable Lab's Peter Hahn has some great suggestions for vinyl listeners looking to enhance their listening experience.


Looking for your first high-end audiophile turntable but don't want to spend more than $2,000 for something that will be your deck for many...

Hi-Fi Components

eCoustics Vintage Audio Editor, Eric Pye, goes record shopping in the land of the rising sun and explores why Japanese hi-fi culture is unlike...

Gift Guides

Thoughtful gift ideas for the vinyl music lover who has everything that won't blow through your Holiday budget.


Acoustic Sounds' new "75 for 75" series features 75 iconic Atlantic Records recordings reissued on 180 gram audiophile vinyl at 45 RPM. The experience...


We test out two inexpensive ways to clean vinyl records from GrooveWasher and Turntable Lab to keep your LPs sounding pristine.


ecoustics is a hi-fi and music magazine offering product reviews, podcasts, news and advice for aspiring audiophiles, home theater enthusiasts and headphone hipsters. Read more

Copyright © 1999-2024 ecoustics | Disclaimer: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

SVS Bluesound PSB Speakers NAD Cambridge Audio Q Acoustics Denon Marantz Focal Naim Audio RSL Speakers