Silver MemberUsername: Superjazzyjames
Post Number: 525
New memberUsername: Berniew
Perth, Western Aust... Australia
Post Number: 8
Personally, I'd go for it. So long as the price is fair, I LIKE having a real disk. I also like downloading hi-res files very much (I don't use pirated stuff), because that's proved to be the best way to get the content I want.
As to the arguement about whether we even need a better format, very well-mastered CD's certainly can sound very good, so long as you play them back on quality equipment. But I've also found that 24bit, 48k or higher sampling rate can offer benefits. You need pretty good playback equipment, and of course, badly made recordings sound bad in any format. Music doesn't necessarily sound better just because it's released in hi-res... but hi-res recordings *potentially* do offer great benefits.
At least, that's going to be what record companies will use to try and sell us new versions of old music, so once again we need to buy new libraries! That's what happened when vinyl gave way to CD, and when DVD took over from video tapes. People wanted their material in these handy new formats. It's a great way to sell the same music all over again. It won't be the last time it happens either, and for that exact same reason.
Downloading is a challenge that record companies still haven't properly figured out how to meet. I'm going to continue to buy music that way, in hi-res whenever possible, because that's the format I want and that's the best way for me to get it right now. As it stands I don't feel it's worth my buying a special player to access SACD disks when I can get the same stuff more cheaply and easilly online. But if there's a mass market once again for music on physical media, I can imagine it'd take off. Certainly the publishers would love that, and if they can do it they will.
And of course, while SACD is effectively copy-protected for most people now, someone will figure out a way around it, and before you know it, ripped versions of new hi-res releases will proliferate for downloading, just as it was with CD and DVD. THere are plenty of clever people out there who are bound to work out how to do it, and offer the world the tools.
Anyone care to comment?
New memberUsername: Jenniedsy
Post Number: 2