• New Products
  • Reviews
  • Roundups
  • Forums
  • All Brands
  • All Topics
  • News
  • Articles
  • What’s New Today?
  • Newsletter Sign-up
ecoustics.com
  • New Products
    • Logitech G560 PC Gaming Speakers Light Up a Room
    • GoPro HERO Action Cam More Fun, Less Cost
    • Focal Listen Wireless Chic Headphones Match any Style
    • Huawei P20 Pro Smartphone Triples Up the Camera (2018 model)
    • Apple Refreshes 9.7-inch iPad with Pencil Support (6th gen, 2018)
    • A/V Receivers
    • Digital Cameras
    • Loudspeakers
    • Smartphones
  • Reviews
    • JBL E55BT Quincy Edition Wireless Headphones Review
    • Master & Dynamic MH40 Headphone Review: Listen in Style
    • Archt One Wireless Speaker Review: 360-degree Musical Bliss
    • Riva Turbo X Bluetooth Speaker Review
    • Koss Pro4S Headphones Review
    • Headphones
    • HDTV & 4K TV
    • Sound Bars
    • Wireless Speakers
  • Roundups
    • Apple iPhone X Review Roundup
    • Apple AirPods Review Roundup
    • Apple iPhone 8 Plus Review Roundup
    • Samsung Galaxy S8 Review Roundup
    • Apple iPhone 7 Review Roundup
  • Forums
  • Brands
    • Apple
    • LG Electronics
    • Microsoft
    • Panasonic
    • Samsung
    • Sony
    • Yamaha
    • All Brands
  • News
  • Articles
  • Topics
    • Home Audio
    • Home Video
    • Home Theater
    • Portable Electronics
    • Photography
    • Car Audio
    • Computers
    • All Topics
  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • Pinterest

  • Instagram

  • Google+

  • YouTube

  • LinkedIn

  • Tumblr

  • RSS

CEA Decries Record Industry Lawsuit Against XM Radio

Loading, please wait...

Record Labels Turn to Courts Once Again to Stifle Innovation, Eliminate Private Home Recording Rights

The following statement was issued today by Consumer Electronics Association (CEAA) Vice President of Government Affairs Michael Petricone regarding the lawsuit filed yesterday against XM Satellite Radio Holdings Inc. by a group of record labels:

“Here they go again. The record industry is returning to the courts in their non-stop efforts to stop new technology, neuter existing products, frustrate consumers and make illegal long-standing consumer home recording activities. Their new target is XM Satellite Radio, one of America’s top technology success stories of the new millennium. XM’s only offense is providing legal and exciting programming options to millions of Americans, while opening new revenue and promotional opportunities for the recording industry.

“The lawsuit announced yesterday is a brazen effort by the labels to strong-arm more money from a successful technology industry startup. XM Radio already is the largest single payer of digital music broadcast royalties. More, the record labels receive royalties on every XM recording device sold as provided by Congress under the Audio Home Recording Act (AHRA).

“Through this lawsuit, the record industry is trying to block private, noncommercial recording off the radio-an activity which Americans have enjoyed for decades, has always been considered legal, and in this case has been expressly recognized by Congress, in the AHRA, as protected from lawsuit.

“The record companies cut a deal, embodied in legislation, which said digital audio recording devices are legal if they do not allow copies of copies. And, throughout their pursuit of the Grokster case, the labels insisted that they had no intention of threatening the sort of in-home, private, noncommercial recording enabled by the devices under question in this suit.

“The products at issue in this lawsuit do not allow redistribution over the Internet or to any other product. They simply allow consumers to time-shift music they are lawfully receiving through subscription fees – fees that support the royalty payments to the labels. No matter how hard the record labels try to stretch the truth, XM has zero resemblance to the old Napster or other peer-to-peer file sharing services.

“The recording industry seems to have developed amnesia about the AHRA into which we and they had substantial input. Under this law, there is no doubt that the satellite recorders at issue in this lawsuit are legal. Specifically, the AHRA says:

‘No action may be brought under this title alleging infringement of copyright based on the manufacture, importation, or distribution of a digital audio recording device, a digital audio recording medium, an analog recording device, or an analog recording medium, or based on the noncommercial use by a consumer of such a device or medium for making digital musical recordings or analog musical recordings.’

“The lawsuit is yet another ambush in the labels’ ongoing war on innovators and consumers. In addition to this lawsuit, the industry is pushing the PERFORM Act in Congress. This legislation would raise royalties and impose new technology mandates on satellite radio. We urge Congress to refrain from acting on this and any related legislation pending an outcome of this lawsuit in the Courts.

“It is time to say ‘enough is enough.’ It is time to put an end to ill-founded lawsuits and over-reaching legislation that effectively impose an ‘innovation tax’ on consumers and technology developers. These ongoing efforts discourage innovation and jeopardize America’s global technology leadership.

“If only the music industry spent as much time adopting new business models as they do filing lawsuits and aggressively lobbying for anti-consumer, anti-technology changes in the law, they might find they can actually expand their market.

“This lawsuit undermines our efforts to work with the recording industry to seek inter-industry cooperation on digital technology issues. On behalf of American consumers and technology innovators, we look forward to standing with XM as it defends this lawsuit. The consumer technology industry will continue to take a strong stand against persistent, punitive, obnoxious and over-reaching efforts by the record labels to control innovation and limit reasonable consumer activities.”

About CEA:
The Consumer Electronics Association (CEA) is the preeminent trade association promoting growth in the consumer technology industry through technology policy, events, research, promotion and the fostering of business and strategic relationships. CEA represents more than 2,100 corporate members involved in the design, development, manufacturing, distribution and integration of audio, video, mobile electronics, wireless and landline communications, information technology, home networking, multimedia and accessory products, as well as related services that are sold through consumer channels. Combined, CEA’s members account for more than $125 billion in annual sales. CEA’s resources are available online at www.CE.org, the definitive source for information about the consumer electronics industry.

CEA also sponsors and manages the International CES – Defining Tomorrow’s Technology. All profits from CES are reinvested into industry services, including technical training and education, industry promotion, engineering standards development, market research and legislative advocacy.

Where to Buy
Loading, please wait...

Leave a Comment

Last Updated:
May 17, 2006
Brian Mitchell @ecoustics

Founder & CEO, ecoustics.com

Related Items
  1. New Products

More in New Products

Logitech G560 PC Gaming Speakers Light Up a Room

Brian Mitchell4 days ago
View This

GoPro HERO Action Cam More Fun, Less Cost

Brian Mitchell5 days ago
View This

Focal Listen Wireless Chic Headphones Match any Style

Brian Mitchell7 days ago
View This

Huawei P20 Pro Smartphone Triples Up the Camera (2018 model)

Brian MitchellMarch 27, 2018
View This

Apple Refreshes 9.7-inch iPad with Pencil Support (6th gen, 2018)

Brian MitchellMarch 27, 2018
View This

Sony Releases Top-of-the-line 85-inch 4K TVs for 2018

Brian MitchellMarch 27, 2018
View This
Scroll for more
Tap

Where to Buy

Loading, please wait...

Top Categories (663)

A/V Receivers, LCD/OLED TVs, Smartphones, Sound Bars, Subwoofers, Streaming Players, Wireless Speakers, ...

Home Audio (2,019)

Loudspeakers, Amplifiers, CD Players, Digital Music Systems, D/A Converters, Stereo Receivers, Preamplifiers, Phono, Integrated Amps, ...

Home Theater (738)

A/V Receivers, Speaker Systems, Remote Controls, A/V Preamplifiers, Home Theater in a Box, Sound Bars, ...

Home Video (1,768)

HDTV & 4K TV, Streaming Players, Projectors, DVR, DVD Players, Satellite TV, Video Game Consoles, ...

Portable Electronics (2,884)

Cell Phones, MP3 Players, Tablets, Headphones, E-Readers, Fit Bands, Smartwatches, ...

Computers (2,575)

Laptops, Monitors, Desktop PC, Hard Drives, Scanners, Networking, Peripherals, PC Speakers, Printers, ...

Photography (1,220)

Digital Cameras, Camcorders, Camera Lenses, Photo Printers, DSLR Cameras, Mirrorless Cameras, ...

Car Audio (250)

Head Units, Car Navigation Systems, Car Speakers, Car Subwoofers, Car Amplifiers, Car Accessories, ...

Brands (452)

Sony, Samsung, Apple, LG Electronics, Canon, Panasonic, Pioneer, Toshiba, Microsoft, HP, ...
ecoustics.com
ecoustics is the unbiased resource for the latest technology news, coolest gadgets, and best consumer electronics. Plus get product reviews, roundups and deals from all over the web on everything electronic. Read more →

Copyright © 1999-2018 ecoustics, LLC | About Us | Contact | Newsletter | Privacy

New 42-Inch Flat Panel Ceiling Mount From Peerless Industries
DVDO Announces Shipment of VRS Precision Deinterlacing Daughter Card for iScan VP30