does anyone think that they shouldnt have thrown that whole love scene in it or the dead army at the end because it wasnt like that in the book i wish they went just by the book it would have made it better and i wish they included the scourching of the shire i loved that part of the book does anyone know if they will have the reg actors for the whole entire really extended verisons and when do those come out
Who knows?! Still a great film, although I think they will milk this trilogy for all its worth. They might be coming out with all kinds of special editions. Peter Jackson has to really extract every bit of money out of these movies. I think his success has gotten to his head, Have you seen King Kong? What a crock! The only thing different I saw was the gorilla's fight scene with the dinosaurs. It's like Jet Li with plenty of hair. That movie did not do any retelling that was worth retelling. And that stupid ending monologue with Jack Black, ugh! What was it..."Beauty killed the beast"??? Geez, how original!
ya i no it was int he book but they ddint just wipe out the army at minas tirith like they did in the moviw it was a real battle i dont like it how they just wiped out the whole army d@mn i wanted to see the burning of the shire it seemed interesting in the book and would have been nice to see in the movie but why did they have to extend that whole love story it wasnt that extravagant in the book it just got annoying and made the two towers movie boring after a while
If you read the extended notes of the book, there are many more references to the love story than you read in the actual story. Peter Jackson probably felt they have to amplify that element to get a wider audience into the theater who were not going to be as enamoured with the battle scenes and burning of the shire as you are.
If you watch the extended edition of Return of the King you will see how Saruman is actually killed off at the begining of the movie (which was cut out of the regular edition of the movie), so it was obvious that Jackson never intended to shoot the actual burning of the shire and the end of Saruman according to the book.
Still the extended edition was faithful to the fact that ultimately wormtongue kills Saurman.
thanks berny maybe ill get it all i need now is some money oh wait a second im neva gona have it new car audio system is gonna kill me errr why does stuff like that have to so expensive wish i had a million dollars and i could just buy some stuff i want